Commentary - Monday, November 16, 2026
By Jared Culver, Legal Analyst
The first two years of the Trump Administration saw remarkable achievements on immigration, including a sustained reduction in border numbers, expansion of 287(g) agreements with cooperative states, and massive funding from Congress to carry out immigration enforcement operations. Particularly important was the expansion of 287(g) programs, which functioned as a force multiplier for ICE in locating criminal aliens.
This was important because of ICE’s “worst of the worst” strategy to target criminal aliens. With local law enforcement assistance, ICE could simply accept transferred custody of apprehended aliens as opposed to seeking aliens on the street amid coordinated violent resistance in some areas. This strategy also allowed ICE to “surge” resources in sanctuary jurisdictions resisting ICE enforcement operations.
Whether or not one agrees with the “worst of the worst” strategy, the recent midterm election makes this strategy obsolete. States like Texas are now going to shift from close cooperation with ICE to primary antagonists. If ICE wants to continue safe removal operations, then they need a new strategy that is not dependent on friendly state support. It is time to focus resources on worksite enforcement operations.
Ain’t nothing but a 287(g) thang
The Trump Administration has made great strides in expanding 287(g) from a forgotten 1996 relic, to a foundational piece in the mass deportation strategy. ICE had extremely limited resources in 2025, and desperately needed force multipliers. The basic idea behind the voluntary program is fostering cooperation in local jails where apprehended criminal aliens can be identified and transferred directly to ICE custody for removal. The Task Force Model (TFM) can even expand law enforcement cooperation beyond the custodial setting. However, though ICE has over 2,300 agreements in over 38 states presently, many of those agreements are in states like Texas. It is safe to assume that the number of 287(g) agreements will decline early next year as Democrats take power.
This is a problem for Trump 2.0 because the “worst of the worst” strategy depended on broad local law enforcement cooperation to succeed. If local law enforcement is releasing criminal aliens, then ICE has to conduct dangerous, resource-intensive criminal fugitive operations. The current DHS Secretary and the President have also been critical of headline-inducing high-profile operations which lead to clashes with protesters and rioters. But without 287(g) agreements, the “worst of the worst” strategy will have to be conducted on the streets of sanctuary cities. This strategy has been overcome by political events and is moot.
Operational Security and Worksite Enforcement
Thus, DHS needs a new strategy to conduct operations in this hostile environment. If they want a strategy that increases the likelihood of high numbers of arrests with lower risk of coordinated violent resistance, then worksite enforcement is the path forward. The majority of illegal aliens, by their own admission, came to the United States for employment opportunities. Too many employers in low-wage, high-violation industries prey on these illegal workers at the expense of American workers.
We know the industries that have a high proportion of illegal labor:
There is no shortage of estimates (some might call them confessions) from the industries themselves. But the gist is that ICE knows there are industries with disproportionate illegal alien representation in the workforce. Some of these industries are mobile, like construction. However, agriculture, restaurants, and meatpacking facilities are stationary, and they come with fixed schedules with set arrival and departure times. In other words, these worksites are controlled environments. For worksites in agriculture and meatpacking, many are also in rural locations that pose difficult logistical challenges for hostile resistance forces seeking to obstruct immigration enforcement.
But even worksite enforcement cannot provide sufficient support for ICE’s removal goals unless the government commits to punishing employers to the fullest extent of the law. Both the Department of Labor and the Department of Justice should coordinate closely with ICE on worksite enforcement to ensure maximum legal liability is applied to employers exploiting foreign labor and impoverishing Americans.
Illegal alien representation in certain low-pay industries is highly disproportionate to their respective representation among the overall population. This means many illegal aliens were trafficked here by cartels specifically to work these low-paying jobs for the profit of employers. Employers see illegal labor as a good business decision only because they believe punitive punishment for breaking the law is highly unlikely. More important even than removal of illegal aliens is the punishing of employers to disprove the notion that reliance on illegal labor is a smart business model. If employers stopped hiring illegal labor, self-deportation numbers would skyrocket.
And self-deportation incentives are key. The Trump Administration has moved decisively to block illegal alien access to public benefits, and it has eliminated a lot of discretionary immigration benefits to illegal aliens like parole and employment authorization. And while there have been aggressive moves against H-1B employers, the same vigor has not routinely been applied to H-2A or H-2B employers. The labor black market has also largely been given a pass due to concerns about affordability.
However, avoiding worksite enforcement did not help the strategy to lower prices. On the other hand, a tight labor market and increased demand for American workers could at least give Americans a chance to afford rent and groceries. An underrated part of “affordability” is having a job with a living wage. Nothing is cheap when you are unemployed or underpaid.
The Trump Administration needs a new strategy for both affordability and immigration enforcement, and worksite enforcement would help on both counts.
Subscribe to receive updates on Congressional action and legislative analysis on immigration issues.